The price looks good on a plane you found. But is it really worth what the seller is asking? Or maybe you're on the other side. You're ready to sell your aircraft, and you need to know what number to put on that listing.
Here's something interesting: aircraft valuation can vary by tens of thousands of dollars for the same make and model based on condition alone. That's a lot of money riding on getting the pricing right.
Figuring out aircraft value isn't like looking up a used car price. Planes are complex machines with histories, maintenance records, and unique conditions that all affect what they're worth. A Cessna 172 from 1975 might sell for $40,000 or $70,000 depending on what's under the hood and in the logbooks. The difference comes down to understanding what makes planes valuable and what drops their price fast.
This guide digs into the tools and methods you need to determine what your airplane is really worth.
Key Takeaways
To determine aircraft value, use pricing guides like VREF or Aircraft Bluebook as your starting point, then adjust for engine time, maintenance history, damage records, and upgrades. Get a professional appraisal for expensive planes or when financing is involved. Always check comparable listings and consider a pre-purchase inspection before buying. The real market value depends on condition, documentation, and current demand for that specific model.
| Factor | What to Know |
| Pricing Guides | VREF and Bluebook give baseline values, updated quarterly |
| Engine Time | Hours since overhaul matters more than total airframe hours |
| Maintenance Records | Complete logbooks add thousands to value |
| Damage History | Past repairs lower price, even if fixed properly |
| Professional Appraisal | Costs $2,000-$4,000, needed for loans and legal purposes |
| Pre-Buy Inspection | $500-$1,000 protects buyers from hidden problems |
| Market Timing | Supply and demand change values by 10-20% |
Why Two Identical Planes Can Have Different Prices
Walk onto any airport ramp and you might see two Cessna 172s parked side by side. Same year. Same model. Same paint color, even. But one is listed at $55,000 and the other at $75,000. How can that be?
The answer is simple. Planes aren't identical just because they rolled off the same assembly line in the same year. What happened to them after that matters a whole lot.
Think about it like two houses on the same street. Both were built in 1980. Both have three bedrooms. But one owner kept everything updated, fixed problems right away, and has receipts for every repair. The other owner did the bare minimum and let small problems slide. You can guess which house sells for more money.
Aviation works the same way. Here's what creates those big price differences:
Engine condition makes or breaks value. One plane might have a fresh engine overhaul with only 200 hours on it. The other might be sitting at 1,600 hours, getting close to the recommended overhaul time. That difference alone can mean $30,000 or more in value. Buyers look at engine time first because replacing an engine costs serious money.
Maintenance history tells the real story. Complete logbooks with every oil change, every annual inspection, and every repair documented add huge value. Missing pages or gaps in records scare buyers away fast. They wonder what else might be hiding.
Damage history never goes away. Even if a gear-up landing was repaired perfectly 10 years ago, it still shows up in the records. Some buyers won't touch a plane with any damage history. Others will buy it but expect a discount. Either way, the price drops.
Upgrades and avionics can help. Modern GPS, glass cockpits, and updated radios make planes easier to sell. But here's the catch. You might spend $40,000 on new avionics and only get $20,000 back when you sell. Upgrades help, but they don't pay for themselves.
Location and use matter too. A Cessna that lived its whole life in dry Arizona will have less corrosion than one based on the coast. A plane used for private family trips will show less wear than one that spent years as a flight school trainer.
The bottom line? Two planes with the same serial number sequence can be worth completely different amounts. That's why you can't just look up a price and call it done. You need to dig into the details.
What Happens When You Get the Price Wrong
Getting aircraft valuation wrong costs money. Sometimes a little. Sometimes a lot. Let's look at both sides.
Say you're buying a plane. You find one that looks perfect. The seller wants $80,000. You're excited, so you skip the pre-purchase inspection to save a few hundred dollars. You buy it. Three months later, your mechanic finds corrosion in the wing spar. The repair costs $15,000. Ouch. You just paid $95,000 for an $80,000 plane. And that's if the market value was even $80,000 to start with.
Or maybe you buy based on the asking price without checking what similar planes actually sell for. You pay $90,000. Then you find out three others just like it sold for $75,000 last month. You overpaid by $15,000 right out of the gate. When you go to sell in a few years, you'll never get that money back.
Now flip it around. You're selling your airplane. You spent $25,000 on upgrades over the years. New paint, new interior, fancy avionics. You add all that up and price your plane at $110,000. But the market says planes like yours sell for $85,000. Your listing sits for months. No offers. You finally drop the price to $82,000 just to get it sold. You left money on the table by pricing too high at first. Buyers moved on to other options.
Here's what goes wrong with bad pricing:
Buyers face hidden costs. You think you got a deal on a cheap plane. Then you discover the engine is almost at its overhaul time. That's another $40,000 you didn't plan for. Or the avionics are so old they don't meet current airspace requirements. Now you need upgrades just to fly where you want to go.
Sellers lose negotiating power. When you price too high, serious buyers skip your listing. The ones who do look will lowball you because the plane sat too long. You end up accepting less than if you'd priced it right from the start.
Financing falls through. Banks need appraisals before they'll loan money. If the appraisal comes back lower than your agreed price, the bank won't cover the difference. The deal dies unless you renegotiate or the buyer comes up with more cash.
Time gets wasted. Months spent waiting for the right buyer or trying to fix a plane you overpaid for. Time you could have spent flying.
The good news? You can avoid all of this. You just need to understand what really drives aircraft value and use the right tools to evaluate it. That's what we're covering next.
The Three Things That Matter Most
Before we get into all the tools and methods, let's talk about the big three. These are the factors that move the needle on aircraft value more than anything else. If you understand these, you're already ahead of most people buying or selling planes.
Engine time is king. Nothing affects value faster than the engine. Planes are expensive to keep flying, and the engine is the single biggest maintenance cost. When a buyer looks at your plane, the first question is usually "How many hours since major overhaul?" That number (called SMOH) tells them how much life is left before the next expensive rebuild.
Here's why it matters so much. A typical piston engine needs an overhaul every 1,800 to 2,000 hours. That overhaul can cost $35,000 to $50,000 or more. If your engine has 1,700 hours on it, the next owner is looking at a huge bill very soon. They're going to want a big discount to cover that cost. If your engine was just overhauled and has only 300 hours, that's $40,000+ of value sitting right there.
Maintenance records are your proof. Complete logbooks are like a clean title on a car. They prove the plane was cared for properly. Every annual inspection, every oil change, every repair should be written down with dates and signatures. Missing pages make buyers nervous. Gaps in the records make them wonder what else is missing.
Good records also prove compliance with Airworthiness Directives (ADs). These are mandatory safety fixes from the FAA. If your logs show every AD was done on time with proper documentation, that's peace of mind for the next owner. If the logs are messy or incomplete, buyers will either walk away or demand a steep discount.
Overall condition tells the whole story. This includes everything else:
- Airframe hours (total time since the plane was built)
- Paint and interior condition
- Avionics and panel upgrades
- Any damage history
- Corrosion issues
- How the plane was stored and used
A well-maintained Cessna 172 with 6,000 total hours can be worth more than a neglected one with 3,000 hours. Why? Because the 6,000-hour plane has complete records, fresh paint, modern radios, and no surprises. The 3,000-hour plane sat outside for years, has sketchy logbooks, and needs work.
These three things work together. A plane with a fresh engine but terrible records won't bring top dollar. A plane with perfect logbooks but a run-out engine needs a price adjustment. A plane with both good engine time and good records, but major damage history, sits somewhere in the middle.
Understanding this foundation helps you make sense of market analysis and appraisal reports. When an aircraft appraiser gives you a number, they're weighing all three of these factors against what similar planes are selling for. When you see a price guide like VREF, those values assume average condition. Your specific plane might be better or worse.
Now that you know what matters most, let's look at the actual tools you'll use to determine what your plane is worth.
What Your Aircraft Is Really Worth: Tools and Methods
You're ready to figure out what your plane is worth. Or what you should pay for one. Good. Let's talk about the tools that get you there. You have options ranging from free online tools to professional appraisals that cost thousands of dollars. Which one you need depends on your situation.
Price Guides: Your Starting Point
VREF and Aircraft Bluebook are the industry standards. These are thick books (or online databases) that list values for just about every aircraft you can think of. They update quarterly based on actual sales data.
Here's how they work. You look up your make and model. Let's say you have a 1978 Cessna 172N. The guide gives you a base value, then shows adjustments for things like total time, engine time, and equipment. You plug in your numbers and get a value range.
VREF is probably the most trusted name. Banks use it. Insurance companies use it. Appraisers use it as a starting point. AOPA members can access basic VREF valuations for free. Professional subscriptions run several hundred dollars per year, but they give you detailed data and historical trends.
Aircraft Bluebook works similarly. Some people prefer one over the other, but they usually come out pretty close. Both are solid references.
The catch? These guides are always 3 to 6 months behind the market. They publish quarterly, and the data they use is older than that. If the aviation market is moving fast, the book values might not match what planes are actually selling for today.
Also, these are just averages. Your specific airplane might be better or worse than average. The guides assume everything is in decent shape with no major issues. If your plane has damage history or corrosion or missing logbooks, the real market value will be lower than the book says.
Online Valuation Tools
Technology is catching up. Some newer tools give you faster, more current data.
PlanePrice from FLYING Magazine uses real-time market data. You can look up any plane listed on their marketplace and see a value range based on recent sales and current listings. It's free to use.
Windsock is available through AOPA membership. It gives you detailed reports including aircraft history, avionics breakdowns, and value comparisons. You get 12 free reports per year as an AOPA member. The data is fresher than printed guides because it updates constantly.
These digital tools are getting better all the time. They pull from actual listings and sales, so they reflect current market conditions faster than quarterly printed books. But they still can't tell you about your specific plane's condition. They give you ranges, not exact numbers.
Use these tools to get a ballpark. If every source says your plane should be worth $70,000 to $85,000, you're probably in that neighborhood. If you're thinking your plane is worth $110,000, you better have really good reasons why.
Professional Appraisals: Three Levels
Sometimes you need more than a guide. You need an expert to look at your specific aircraft and tell you what it's worth. That's where professional appraisals come in.
Basic/Pricing Guide Appraisal is the cheapest option. An appraiser uses VREF or Bluebook, plugs in your details, and gives you a number. Cost is usually a few hundred dollars. This works fine for simple situations, but it's not much different from what you could do yourself.
Desktop Appraisal is the middle option. A certified aircraft appraiser reviews your logbooks, equipment list, photos, and maintenance records remotely. They compare your plane to recent sales. They look for red flags in the paperwork. Then they give you a detailed report with their opinion of value. This typically costs $1,000 to $2,000 and takes a few days.
Desktop appraisals are good when you need something official but don't want to pay for a full inspection. Lenders sometimes accept these. Insurance companies might use them.
Physical/Certified Appraisal is the full deal. A certified appraiser comes to see your plane in person. They inspect the airframe, look at the engine, check panels and systems, take photos, and review all your paperwork. Then they write a comprehensive report (usually 20+ pages) with their findings and value conclusion.
This level costs $2,000 to $4,000 for general aviation planes. Business jets and turboprops can cost $15,000 or more for a proper appraisal. But you get what you pay for. This report will stand up in court, satisfy any bank for financing, and give you complete confidence in the value.
When do you need the expensive option? If you're buying or selling something unusual, like a modified aircraft or a rare model. If you need it for estate planning or legal purposes. If a bank requires it for a loan. Or if you're spending six figures and want absolute certainty before you sign.
Checking Comparable Aircraft
One of the smartest things you can do is check what similar planes are actually listed for and selling for. This is your real-time market analysis.
Go to websites like Controller, Trade-A-Plane, and Barnstormers. Search for your make and model. Look at planes from similar years with similar equipment and similar time. What are people asking?
But here's the trick. Asking prices aren't selling prices. A plane listed at $95,000 might sit for months and eventually sell for $82,000. You need to figure out which listings are realistic and which ones are wishful thinking.
How do you tell? Look at how long listings have been up. If a plane has been for sale for six months, the price is probably too high. Look at the details in the ad. Are the logs complete? Any damage history mentioned? What's the engine time?
Talk to brokers too. They know what planes are actually selling for, not just what people are asking. A good broker can tell you "Yeah, that model is hot right now, selling in two weeks at asking price" or "Those are sitting, you'll need to come down 10% to get interest."
The more comparables you check, the better feel you get for the market. Don't just look at one or two listings. Find at least five or six similar planes and see where the cluster is. That's your real market.
Engine Time: The Number That Changes Everything
Let's get into the details on why engine time matters so much. This is the single biggest factor in aircraft valuation, and understanding it will save you thousands.
What SMOH and TBO Mean
SMOH stands for Since Major Overhaul. It's the number of hours the engine has run since it was last completely rebuilt. When a plane is brand new, this number starts at zero. As you fly, the hours add up.
TBO stands for Time Between Overhaul. This is the manufacturer's recommended hours before the engine needs to be overhauled again. For most piston engines, TBO is somewhere between 1,400 and 2,400 hours, depending on the engine model. Lycoming and Continental (the big piston engine makers) publish these numbers.
Here's a real example. You're looking at a plane with a Lycoming O-360 engine. The TBO for that engine is 2,000 hours. The logbooks show it was overhauled in 2015, and it now has 1,200 hours SMOH. That means the engine has about 800 hours of life left before it needs another overhaul.
How Engine Time Affects the Price
Now here's where it gets expensive. A major engine overhaul costs $35,000 to $50,000 or more. That's a huge chunk of change. Buyers know this, so they do math.
If the engine in that plane we just talked about has 800 hours left, and you fly 100 hours per year, you've got about 8 years before you need to spend $40,000. Not bad. The buyer might pay close to market value for that plane.
But if the engine has 1,800 hours SMOH out of a 2,000-hour TBO, you've only got 200 hours left. At 100 hours per year, that's two years before you need an overhaul. The buyer is going to want a big discount. They might ask for $30,000 off the price to cover the upcoming expense.
Here's where it gets interesting. Industry folks say that once an engine hits 80% of TBO, it's considered "run-out" for pricing purposes. That means buyers treat it like it needs an overhaul now, even if it has a couple hundred hours left. So in our 2,000-hour TBO example, once you hit 1,600 hours, your value drops hard.
The Sweet Spot for Resale Value
The best time to sell a plane is when the engine is at mid-time. That's around 50% of TBO. Why? Because buyers see plenty of life left, but the engine has also proven itself reliable.
A brand-new zero-time engine sounds great, right? Sometimes yes, sometimes no. New overhauls can have "infant mortality" issues. Parts that fail in the first 100 to 400 hours. Plus, you paid for that overhaul and you won't get all that money back when you sell. Aviation upgrades rarely return 100% of their cost.
Mid-time engines are the sweet spot. They've burned off any break-in issues. They still have years of life left. And the price reflects that balance.
Quality of Overhaul Matters Too
Not all overhauls are created equal. A factory remanufactured engine from Lycoming or Continental is worth more than a field overhaul done by a random shop. Why? Because factory remans get completely torn down, measured, and rebuilt to new tolerances with new parts. They come with a fresh logbook entry that basically says "this is like a new engine."
Field overhauls can be great if done by a reputable shop. But quality varies. Some shops cut corners. They reuse parts that should be replaced. They don't follow all the service bulletins. The result is an overhaul that might not make it to TBO.
When you're evaluating a plane, check who did the engine work. Was it a well-known shop with a good reputation? Are there photos of the work? Do they have all the receipts and documentation? These details matter.
Maintenance Records: The Aircraft's Report Card
If the engine is the heart of the plane, the logbooks are the medical records. They tell you everything about how this aircraft lived its life. Good records add serious value. Bad records kill deals.
Complete Logbooks Add Thousands to Value
Every plane should have three sets of logs: airframe, engine, and propeller. Some planes combine them, some keep them separate. Doesn't matter, as long as everything is documented.
What should be in there? Every single thing that happened to the plane:
- Annual inspections with dates and signatures
- Oil changes and filter replacements
- Repairs and part replacements
- Airworthiness Directive (AD) compliance
- Service bulletin compliance
- Major modifications and upgrades
- Damage and repair history
Complete logs that go back to when the plane was new are gold. They show an unbroken chain of care. Buyers love that.
Missing pages are red flags. If there's a gap from 1995 to 2000, what happened during those years? Nobody knows. That mystery scares buyers away. They assume the worst.
Messy, hard-to-read logs are almost as bad. If you can't tell what was done when, how do you prove the plane is airworthy? Professional appraisers will spend hours going through logs to verify everything. If they can't make sense of them, your value drops.
Airworthiness Directives (ADs) Compliance
ADs are mandatory safety fixes issued by the FAA. Every plane has them. Some are one-time fixes. Some recur every year or every 100 hours.
Your logs need to show that every applicable AD was completed and signed off. This isn't optional. If an AD isn't done, the plane isn't legally airworthy. You can't sell it until you fix that.
Some ADs are cheap and easy. Others are expensive nightmares. Buyers check which ADs apply to your specific model and year. If there's a recurring AD that costs $2,000 every year, they factor that into the operating costs.
During a pre-purchase inspection, mechanics always check AD compliance. It's one of the first things they look for. If they find an open AD, the deal might be dead until you fix it.
Annual Inspections and Maintenance History
Every plane needs an annual inspection by a certified mechanic. This inspection checks hundreds of items to make sure the plane is safe to fly. The logs should show this happened every year, on time, with no gaps.
But it's not just about having the annual done. It's about what the annual reveals. If your logs show the same mechanic doing thorough work year after year, that's reassuring. If the logs show a different shop every year, or if the write-ups are super brief, buyers wonder if corners were cut.
The pattern of maintenance tells a story. Did the owner fix things right away, or defer everything until the next annual? Are there upgrades and improvements over the years, or just the bare minimum to stay legal?
Quality shops also matter. A plane maintained by a dealer or factory-authorized shop carries more weight than one maintained by an unknown mechanic working out of his garage. That's not always fair, but it's reality. Reputation counts.
Damage History: What Buyers Fear Most
Let's talk about the elephant in the hangar. Damage history. Even if repairs were perfect, damage still affects value. Here's why and how much.
How Past Damage Lowers Value
About 20% of buyers won't even look at a plane with any damage history. Period. They just move on to the next listing. That immediately shrinks your pool of potential buyers.
The other 80% might consider it, but they'll want a discount. How much depends on what happened and how it was fixed.
Minor damage includes things like:
- Wingtip scraped in the hangar
- Propeller strike on a taxiway light
- Door ding from another plane
- Small dents in the cowling
If these were fixed properly with proper documentation, the impact might only be 5-10% off the value. Some buyers won't care at all if it happened 20 years ago and everything looks great now.
Major damage is different:
- Gear-up landing
- Runway excursion with structural damage
- Hard landing that required spar replacement
- Major corrosion repair that needed doubler plates
This kind of damage can drop your value by 15-30% or more. Even if a top shop did the repairs and everything is perfect now, that history never goes away. It's always in the logs.
The Importance of Documentation
If your plane has damage history, documentation is everything. Buyers want to see:
- Photos of the damage before repair
- Detailed work orders and repair procedures
- Invoices showing what was replaced
- FAA Form 337 for major repairs
- Sign-off from the repair shop
- Follow-up inspections showing everything is solid
The more documentation you have, the better. It proves the repair was done right. It shows you're being transparent. It gives the buyer confidence.
Discovering hidden damage during a pre-purchase inspection is a deal killer. Buyers feel like they were lied to. Even if the seller didn't know about it, trust is gone. The deal usually dies or the price gets hammered.
Be upfront about any damage. Mention it in your listing. Have all the paperwork ready. You'll get better buyers who appreciate honesty.
Corrosion: Damage You Can't Always See
Corrosion is sneaky. It hides under paint, inside wing spars, in the tail cone. By the time you can see it from the outside, it might be serious.
Aviation inspectors know where to look. They check common corrosion spots:
- Wing attach points
- Battery compartments
- Belly where water collects
- Around fuel tanks
- Anywhere dissimilar metals touch
Planes based on the coast or in humid climates have higher corrosion risk. Salt air is murder on aluminum. Even planes that spent time in these areas years ago can have issues pop up later.
Corrosion repairs don't always solve the problem permanently. It can come back. That's why buyers are extra careful about it. Some won't touch a plane with any corrosion history.
If you're buying, insist on a thorough corrosion inspection as part of your pre-buy. If you're selling and you know there's been corrosion, disclose it and show what was done to fix it.
Avionics and Upgrades: Do They Pay Off?
You spent $35,000 putting in a fancy new panel with glass displays and modern GPS. That should add $35,000 to your plane's value, right? Not quite. Let's talk about what upgrades really do for aircraft value.
Modern Electronics Buyers Want
Today's buyers expect certain things. Planes with old radios and steam gauges are harder to sell. Modern avionics do add value, especially:
ADS-B Out is mandatory. If your plane doesn't have it, you can't fly in most controlled airspace. This isn't an upgrade, it's required equipment. Buyers expect it to be there.
GPS navigation is basically standard now. An IFR-capable GPS like a Garmin 430 or 650 makes the plane more useful. Buyers will pay more for it than for a plane with only old VOR radios.
Glass cockpits (like Garmin G500 or Aspen displays) are popular. They replace old analog gauges with modern screens. They look professional, they're easier to read, and they integrate with other systems. Buyers like them.
Autopilot systems make long flights easier. A good autopilot like a GFC 500 or an older Century III adds value, especially for IFR planes.
Engine monitors help you take care of the engine and catch problems early. Buyers appreciate these.
The 50-70% Rule
Here's the hard truth. You typically recover 50-70% of what you spent on upgrades when you sell. Sometimes less.
Let's say you spent $40,000 on a panel upgrade. That might add $20,000 to $28,000 to your plane's value. You lost $12,000 to $20,000 on the deal.
Why? Because technology gets old fast. That fancy GPS you installed five years ago has been replaced by two newer models. What was cutting-edge is now just average. Also, the next owner might want different equipment than what you installed.
This doesn't mean upgrades are a waste. If you're keeping the plane and flying it for years, modern avionics make your life better. They're worth it for the utility and safety. Just don't expect to get your money back when you sell.
The best upgrades from a value perspective are the ones that make the plane legal and functional. Adding ADS-B Out when your plane didn't have it? Good investment. It was required anyway. Replacing a dead radio with a modern one? Makes sense. Going from a working older panel to the absolute latest greatest technology? That's for your enjoyment, not for resale value.
Paint and Interior Improvements
Fresh paint can add $5,000 to $10,000 to your plane's value. A nice new interior can do the same. But here's the catch.
Paint and interior jobs cost way more than that. A good paint job runs $15,000 to $25,000 or more depending on the aircraft. A complete interior might be $10,000 to $15,000. So you're spending $25,000 to add maybe $10,000 to $15,000 in value.
Again, this isn't about getting your money back. It's about making the plane nicer to own and easier to sell. A plane with faded paint and torn seats will sit on the market forever. A plane with fresh cosmetics sells faster.
But buyers are smart. They know nice paint can hide corrosion and other problems. They know a fancy interior doesn't tell them anything about the engine or airframe condition. So they appreciate the cosmetics, but they still want to see the important stuff underneath.
If you're selling, having decent paint and interior helps. If you're buying, don't pay a huge premium just because the plane looks pretty. Make sure the mechanics are solid first.
The Pre-Purchase Inspection: A Buyer's Must-Do
You found a plane you love. The price seems fair. The seller says everything is great. Time to buy it, right? Wrong. Time for a pre-purchase inspection. This step saves buyers from expensive mistakes.
What a Pre-Buy Inspection Is
A pre-buy (also called pre-purchase inspection) is when you hire a mechanic to examine the plane before you buy it. This isn't an annual inspection, though there's some overlap. The goal is to find problems and verify the plane is what the seller claims it is.
The mechanic will:
- Review all the logbooks in detail
- Check AD and service bulletin compliance
- Look at the airframe for damage and corrosion
- Inspect the engine (often including a borescope to look inside the cylinders)
- Test the avionics and systems
- Check control surfaces and cables
- Look for fluid leaks and worn parts
- Verify the serial numbers and paperwork match
For small planes like a Cessna 172, this costs $500 to $1,500 and takes most of a day. For complex or larger planes, it can cost several thousand dollars and take a week.
Yes, that's real money. But it's cheap insurance against buying a $70,000 plane that needs $30,000 in immediate repairs.
Choosing the Right Mechanic
Never, ever use the seller's regular mechanic for your pre-buy. That person has a relationship with the seller. They might not be objective. They might be the one who's been signing off questionable annuals for years.
Find an independent mechanic who:
- Specializes in that type of airplane
- Has no connection to the seller
- Has a good reputation in the owner community
- Will be thorough and honest with you
Where do you find them? Check type-specific owner forums. Ask other owners of that same model. Call flight schools or FBOs at nearby airports and ask who they recommend for that particular aircraft.
It's worth traveling to get the right person. If the plane is in Florida but the best mechanic for that model is in Georgia, pay to ferry the plane there for the inspection. The expertise is worth it.
Common Problems Found in Pre-Buys
Here's what mechanics often discover:
Undocumented repairs - Something was fixed but never logged properly. Now you don't know if it was done right.
Corrosion - Especially in hidden areas like wing attach points or the tail cone. Can be expensive to fix.
Upcoming expensive maintenance - The engine is close to TBO, or a major inspection is due soon. This affects how much you should pay.
Non-compliant modifications - Someone installed something without the proper paperwork or STC. You might have to remove it or get it properly approved.
Inoperative equipment - Radios or instruments that don't work. The seller might not have mentioned it.
Logbook problems - Missing pages, unclear entries, gaps in the timeline.
Worn components - Tires, brakes, belts, hoses that need replacing soon.
None of these are necessarily deal breakers, but you need to know about them. They affect the pricing negotiation.
What to Do With the Findings
Once the inspection is done, the mechanic gives you a discrepancy list. Now you have options:
Walk away if the problems are too serious or expensive. You lose the inspection cost, but you avoided buying a problem plane.
Negotiate a price reduction to cover the cost of repairs. If the mechanic finds $8,000 worth of needed work, ask the seller to drop the price by that amount.
Ask the seller to fix the issues before closing. Get everything in writing about what will be fixed and who pays for it.
Accept it as-is if the problems are minor and you expected them. Maybe you knew the paint was old or the interior needed work.
The pre-buy gives you leverage. It also gives you peace of mind if everything checks out. Either way, it's money well spent.
Market Conditions That Change Values
The aviation market isn't static. Aircraft value changes based on what's happening in the economy and in the aircraft market specifically. Understanding these patterns helps you time your purchase or sale.
Supply and Demand in Your Aircraft Type
Popular models hold value better. A Cessna 172 is one of the most common training planes ever built. There's always demand. Parts are easy to find. Mechanics know how to work on them. Values stay relatively stable.
Rare or orphaned models are trickier. If the manufacturer went out of business or stopped supporting that model, parts get hard to find. Fewer mechanics know the systems. These planes can be great deals if you're willing to deal with the challenges, but they're harder to sell later.
Right now, if there are 50 of your model for sale and only a handful of buyers looking, prices drop. Sellers compete by lowering prices. If there are only five for sale and lots of buyers searching, prices go up. Sellers can hold firm on their number.
Check how many similar planes are currently listed. Look at how long they've been on the market. This tells you if it's a buyer's market or a seller's market.
Geographic Location Matters
Where the plane is based affects value. Planes from coastal areas might have corrosion concerns. Buyers from inland states sometimes avoid them entirely.
Northern planes might have dealt with cold weather, ice, and snow. Some buyers worry about how they were stored during winter.
Southwestern planes from dry climates like Arizona or New Mexico often bring premium prices. No corrosion risk. No harsh weather. These planes tend to be in better condition.
Sometimes it's worth traveling to buy the right plane. A buyer in New York might fly to Arizona to pick up a plane because the quality is better. The extra travel cost pays off in the condition you get.
Best Time to Buy or Sell
The aircraft market has seasonal patterns. Spring and summer are busy. People want to buy planes when flying weather is good. Sellers get more interest and better prices during these months.
Fall and winter are slower. Fewer buyers are shopping. Sellers might be more willing to negotiate. If you're buying, you might find better deals in October or November.
Economic conditions matter too. When the economy is strong, people have money to spend on planes. Demand goes up, prices follow. When the economy is shaky, discretionary purchases like aircraft slow down. Prices soften.
Interest rates affect financing costs. When rates are low, more buyers can afford to borrow money for a plane. When rates go up, buyers have to pay more in interest, so they offer less for the plane.
Right now, the market has cooled from the hot 2021-2022 period. There's more inventory available. Buyers have more choices and more negotiating power than they did a couple years ago.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Let's talk about what not to do. These mistakes cost people thousands of dollars every year.
If You're Selling
Pricing based on what you spent - You put $50,000 into upgrades and maintenance over the years. You want that money back. But buyers don't care what you spent. They care what the plane is worth today in the current market. Price it based on comparables, not your costs.
Not disclosing problems - Hiding damage history or corrosion might work until the pre-buy inspection. Then the buyer finds it, gets angry, and walks away. Or worse, they buy it, find out later, and you face legal problems. Be honest up front.
Overvaluing your upgrades - You spent $30,000 on avionics. That doesn't mean you get to add $30,000 to the market value. Remember the 50-70% rule. Price accordingly.
Poor presentation - Bad photos, incomplete ads, no response to inquiries. Make it easy for buyers to see what you have. Get the plane cleaned up. Take good pictures. Answer questions quickly.
Being unrealistic about condition - Your plane is 40 years old with faded paint and worn interior. It's not "excellent" condition. Be honest in your description.
If You're Buying
Skipping the pre-purchase inspection - This is the biggest mistake buyers make. Saving $1,000 on the inspection can cost you $20,000 in repairs. Always get an independent pre-buy.
Falling in love before the inspection - Don't get emotionally attached until after the mechanic says it's good. Stay objective until you have all the facts.
Not researching the model's issues - Every aircraft type has known problems. Some have recurring ADs. Some have parts that are hard to find. Some have expensive maintenance quirks. Research these before you commit.
Ignoring total cost of ownership - The purchase price is just the start. What's the annual insurance? Hangar costs? Fuel burn? Engine reserve? Add it all up before you decide you can afford it.
Not checking insurance costs - Some planes are expensive to insure. Some require lots of flight time in type before you can get coverage. Call an aviation insurance agent before you make an offer.
Trusting incomplete logbooks - Missing pages mean unknown history. That's a risk. Don't assume everything was fine during those missing years.
Buying the first plane you see - Look at several. Compare them. Learn what's out there. You'll make a better decision.
Step-by-Step: Finding the Right Price
Let's put this all together with a clear process you can follow.
For Sellers
Step 1: Gather all records - Find every logbook, every receipt, every piece of paperwork related to your plane. Organize it so buyers can review it easily.
Step 2: Check pricing guides - Look up your plane in VREF or Aircraft Bluebook. Get the baseline value for your year and model.
Step 3: Research comparables - Search Controller, Trade-A-Plane, and Barnstormers for similar planes. Note what they're asking and how long they've been listed.
Step 4: Consider professional help - For expensive planes, get a desktop or physical appraisal. It costs money but gives you confidence in your price.
Step 5: Factor in your condition honestly - Is your engine mid-time or run-out? Are your logs perfect or messy? Any damage history? Adjust your price accordingly.
Step 6: Set a realistic asking price - Based on all the above, pick a number that's competitive. You can always negotiate down, but if you start too high, buyers will skip your listing.
Step 7: Be ready to prove value - When serious buyers ask questions, have answers. Have documentation ready. Be transparent about any issues.
For Buyers
Step 1: Research the make and model - Learn about that specific airplane. What are common problems? What do owners say? What's the typical operating cost?
Step 2: Check pricing guides - See what VREF or Bluebook says that model should cost. Get a feel for the range.
Step 3: Find several options - Don't just look at one plane. Find 3-5 that might work. Compare them.
Step 4: Review available information - Look at photos carefully. Read the ad details. Ask the seller questions about engine time, damage history, and equipment.
Step 5: Schedule independent pre-buy - Line up a good mechanic before you make an offer. Make your offer contingent on a satisfactory inspection.
Step 6: Compare to market - Is the asking price in line with other similar planes? If it's higher, why? If it's lower, what's wrong?
Step 7: Negotiate based on findings - After the pre-buy, you have facts. Use them to negotiate fairly. If the plane is as advertised, pay the agreed price. If problems were found, ask for adjustments.
Step 8: Don't be afraid to walk away - If the numbers don't work or the plane has too many issues, move on. Another plane will come along.
When to Hire Professionals
Sometimes you need expert help. Here's when to bring in the pros.
Aircraft Appraisers
Hire a certified aircraft appraiser when:
- You need financing and the bank requires it
- You're dealing with estate or legal matters
- The plane is expensive or unusual
- You want absolute certainty on value
- You're buying or selling something rare or modified
Look for appraisers with credentials like:
- ASA (American Society of Appraisers)
- PAAO (Professional Aircraft Appraisal Organization)
- NAAA (National Aircraft Appraisal Association)
- USPAP certification for legal work
Expect to pay $2,000 to $4,000 for a thorough physical appraisal of a small plane. Business jets cost more.
Aircraft Brokers
A broker can help you find a plane or sell yours. They earn a commission (usually 5-10% of the sale price), but they bring value:
- Access to off-market planes not publicly listed
- Knowledge of current market analysis and trends
- Help with paperwork and closing
- Negotiation experience
- Screening of buyers or finding qualified buyers
For first-time buyers or sellers, a good broker can be worth the commission. They save you time and help you avoid mistakes.
Specialized Mechanics
Your relationship with a good mechanic starts before you buy. Find someone who:
- Knows your specific aircraft type
- Has A&P (Airframe & Powerplant) certification
- Preferably has IA (Inspection Authorization) for annual inspections
- Has a good reputation in the owner community
Use this person for your pre-buy inspection. Then keep using them for ongoing maintenance. A mechanic who knows your plane's history is valuable.
Making Your Final Decision
You've done the research. You've checked the pricing guides, looked at comparables, maybe even got an appraisal. You understand engine time, maintenance records, and damage history. You know what upgrades are worth and what they're not.
Now it's time to determine what you'll pay or what you'll accept.
Remember that aircraft valuation is part science, part art. The guides give you numbers. The comparables show you the market. But your specific airplane is unique. Your situation is unique.
A plane with 1,500 hours SMOH might be a bad deal for someone who only flies 50 hours per year. They'll hit TBO in 10 years, which might be perfect timing. But for someone flying 200 hours per year, that's only 2-3 years away. Very different situations.
A Cessna with damage history might be fine for someone who plans to keep it forever. But if you might sell in a couple years, that damage history will make resale harder.
The key is using all these tools together. Don't rely on just one source. Use VREF and comparables and professional opinions. Look at the whole picture.
And trust your gut. If something feels off, if the seller is evasive, if the numbers don't add up, walk away. There are always more planes out there.
On the other hand, if you found a well-maintained aircraft with complete records, good engine time, and a fair price, don't let it slip away by overthinking. Good planes sell fast.
The best deals happen when both sides are informed and honest. The seller knows what they have and prices it fairly. The buyer does their homework and makes a reasonable offer. Everyone walks away feeling good.
That's what you're aiming for.
Ready to Determine Your Aircraft's True Value?
Aircraft valuation doesn't have to be complicated. You just need the right tools and knowledge to make a smart decision.
Start with pricing guides like VREF to get your baseline. Check comparable listings to see the current market. Factor in your engine time and maintenance records honestly. Get a professional appraisal if the situation calls for it. And if you're buying, always get that pre-purchase inspection.
Whether you're looking to buy your first plane or sell one you've owned for years, understanding aircraft value protects you from costly mistakes. Take your time. Do the research. Ask the questions.
The aviation community is full of people who love to help. Talk to other owners. Join type-specific forums. Call brokers and appraisers to get their insights. The more you know, the better decision you'll make.
At Flying411, we understand that determining aircraft value can feel overwhelming. Our team has years of experience helping buyers and sellers navigate the market analysis process. We're here to answer your questions and guide you to a fair deal. Whether you're ready to buy, sell, or just want to know what your plane is worth, reach out to us. Let's figure this out together.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often should I get my aircraft appraised?
You should get a professional appraisal whenever you need financing, for insurance purposes when required, or if you're involved in estate planning or legal matters. For general knowledge, checking online valuation tools annually is usually enough. If you're planning to sell within the next year, getting an appraisal 6-12 months ahead helps you price correctly and make any improvements that might boost value before listing.
Can I finance an aircraft that's close to engine TBO?
Financing an aircraft near engine TBO is more difficult but not impossible. Most lenders prefer engines at less than 75% of TBO. If the engine is closer to overhaul time, you might need a larger down payment (30-40% instead of 20%), face higher interest rates, or get a shorter loan term. Some lenders won't finance planes with engines over 80% of TBO at all. Your best bet is shopping multiple lenders and being upfront about the engine time.
What's the difference between market value and insured value?
Market value is what the aircraft would actually sell for in the current market based on condition, comparable sales, and demand. Insured value is what your insurance company will pay if the plane is totaled. These numbers should be close, but insured value might be slightly higher to cover replacement costs. Insurance companies typically require an appraisal to set insured value, and they'll adjust it annually based on depreciation and market conditions.
Do I need to report upgrades to my insurance company?
Yes, you should report all avionics and equipment upgrades to your insurance company. Adding new GPS, glass cockpits, or other expensive equipment increases your plane's value, which should increase your insured value too. If you have a total loss and haven't reported a $40,000 panel upgrade, your payout will be based on the old equipment. Also, some modifications might affect your premium or coverage, so always notify your insurer before making changes.
How long does it typically take to sell an aircraft?
In a balanced market, a well-priced aircraft in good condition typically sells in 2-4 months. Popular models like a Cessna 172 might sell faster (1-2 months) if priced right. Unusual or expensive planes can take 6-12 months or longer. The keys to faster sales are competitive pricing, complete documentation, good presentation, and realistic condition description. Overpriced planes can sit for a year or more, while underpriced ones might sell in weeks.